By Dr. Andreas Boettcher, D.C., Functional Medicine, B.S. Health/Exercise Science

3x Ironman Triathlete, Master's Men's Physique Competitor, Medication Free at 55

www.ItsOnlyHalftime.com

The Fiber Myth: What Most People Get Wrong About Fiber, Gut Health, and Hormone Optimization

For decades, fiber has been marketed as a nutritional “must-have,” a miracle ingredient that you should pile onto every meal to improve digestion, lower cholesterol, and even balance hormones. But like many long-held nutrition beliefs, the truth is far more nuanced — and in many cases, completely misunderstood.

As men and women look to optimize their gut health, metabolism, and hormone production naturally, it’s critical to understand what fiber actually does, what it doesn’t do, and why more isn’t always better. In the IOH approach, we take a whole-food, biologically aligned strategy that prioritizes function over fad — including a deep focus on gut integrity [READ GUT RESTORE PROTOCOL ARTICLE] which must be addressed before fiber intake even becomes relevant.

MYTH #1: “More fiber is always better.”

THE TRUTH:There is a therapeutic range — and too much fiber can backfire.

Most general recommendations tell people to aim for 30–40+ grams of fiber per day, but that ignores individualized gut function and the current state of the microbiome.

Current evidence shows that 18–25 grams per day from whole-food sources is ideal for most adults. Anything significantly above this — especially from supplemental or processed sources — can create problems:

• Loose stools and faster transit time

• Binding of key minerals (zinc, magnesium, calcium)

• Reduced absorption of crucial fat-soluble vitamins (A, D, E, K)

• Increased bloating and inflammation

• Worsened dysbiosis

• Suboptimal hormone production (especially testosterone)

Excess fiber becomes especially problematic when the gut lining is inflamed or disrupted — which is why foundational gut repair [READ GUT RESTORE PROTOCOL ARTICLE] must come first.

MYTH #2: “All fiber is the same.”

THE TRUTH:Whole-food fiber behaves VERY differently from supplemental fiber.

There is an enormous difference between:

1. Naturally occurring fiber from whole foods, and

2. Extracted or isolated fiber added to packaged foods, cereals, bars, or powders

Natural fiber from sweet potatoes, carrots, berries, yams, and select vegetables is paired with polyphenols, enzymes, and nutrients beneficial to the microbiome.

Isolated or added fiber can:

• Ferment too aggressively

• Increase bloating and discomfort

• Irritate the gut lining

• Bind essential minerals

• Worsen inflammation if the gut is not healed

This is why the IOH approach avoids adding supplemental fibers during the gut-healing phase [READ GUT RESTORE PROTOCOL ARTICLE].

MYTH #3: “Fiber automatically improves gut health.”

THE TRUTH:Fiber can help — but ONLY if your gut is already healthy.

If the gut lining is irritated, inflamed, or permeable, fiber can actually make symptoms worse.

This includes individuals with:

• Dysbiosis

• Leaky gut

• IBS

• High inflammation

• Enzyme deficiencies

• Low stomach acid

• Poor bile flow

In these cases, piling on fiber only creates additional digestive burden. That’s why the IOH philosophy begins with gut repair, inflammation reduction, and improved nutrient absorption— the cornerstone of the Gut Restore Protocol [READ GUT RESTORE PROTOCOL ARTICLE].

Once digestive balance returns, then — and only then — do we evaluate fiber tolerance.

MYTH #4: “High-fiber diets improve testosterone.”

THE TRUTH:Too much fiber may LOWER testosterone by binding key nutrients.

Testosterone production relies heavily on nutrients such as:

• Zinc

• Magnesium

• Cholesterol

• Vitamin D

• Adequate fat absorption

Here’s the problem:

Fiber binds minerals — especially zinc — which is essential for testosterone production and LH signaling.

Additionally, high fiber intake:

• Reduces fat absorption

• Lowers availability of vitamins A, D, E, and K

• Increases bowel transit time (less nutrient extraction)

For men looking to optimize testosterone, mineral sufficiency and gut absorption matter significantly more than high fiber intake. This is why hormone optimization begins with gut optimization [READ GUT RESTORE PROTOCOL ARTICLE] rather than increasing fiber for its own sake.

MYTH #5: “If you’re not ‘regular,’ you just need more fiber.”

THE TRUTH:Stool issues almost always point to gut dysfunction — not fiber deficiency.

Constipation, loose stools, or alternating patterns rarely indicate a lack of fiber. Instead, they are often signs of:

• Low stomach acid

• Insufficient bile production

• Dysbiosis

• Gut irritation

• Enzyme insufficiencies

• Hidden food sensitivities

• Chronic stress

• Poor circadian alignment

Simply adding fiber masks symptoms while allowing the root dysfunction to continue.

A proper gut-restoration plan [READ GUT RESTORE PROTOCOL ARTICLE] corrects the underlying cause — and stool patterns normalize naturally.

So, how much fiber do you ACTUALLY need?

For adults following the IOH approved whole-food meal plan:

18–25 grams per day

from natural whole foods
is the optimal range.

This supports:

• Smooth digestion

• Balanced microbiome function

• Stable blood sugar

• Efficient nutrient absorption

• Optimal hormone production

• Reduced inflammation

This range keeps fiber high enough to provide benefits but low enough to avoid nutrient binding, gut irritation, and testosterone disruption.

Where IOH-approved fiber naturally comes from

The IOH meal plan provides a balanced dose of functional, biologically compatible fiber from:

• Sweet potatoes

• Yams

• Carrots

• Berries

• Spaghetti squash

• Select non-irritating vegetables, including:

  • Zucchini

  • Asparagus

  • Green beans

  • Cauliflower (small amounts if tolerated)

  • Cucumbers

  • Mushrooms

  • Bell peppers

  • Bok choy

  • Snap peas

  • Cabbage (lightly cooked)

No powders.
No added bran.
No processed grains.
No fiber supplements that disrupt gut balance.

Just whole food — the way your microbiome was designed to operate.

The Bottom Line

Fiber is beneficial — but only when consumed in the right amount, from the right sources, and at the right time in your health journey.

The belief that “more is better” is outdated and often harmful. Hormone optimization requires a gut that absorbs nutrients efficiently, not one overloaded with bulk.

Start with gut repair [READ GUT RESTORE PROTOCOL ARTICLE].
Support nutrient absorption.
Eat whole foods.
And let fiber take care of itself naturally.

⚡️ Ready To Fix the Terrain With the Most Comprehensive Natural Approach to Mens Health?

If you’d like to go deeper — to uncover the root causes behind your energy, hormones, metabolism, and performance — I invite you to book a complimentary consultation.

Together, we’ll review your health history and goals and determine if our Peak Performance Protocol based on your lab analysis, genetics, and lifestyle data is right for you!

👉Click here to schedule your complimentary consultation.

To learn more about our approach and success stories, visit www.ItsOnlyHalftime.com where we help men like you turn your second half into your best half naturally!

Finish Strong,

Dr. Andreas

Still Kickin' A** Medication Free at 55 Despite What the "Narrative" Would Like You To Believe!

Medical Disclaimer:

The information provided in this article is for educational and informational purposes only and is not intended as medical advice. It should not replace professional consultation, diagnosis, or treatment. Always consult your healthcare provider before making any changes to your health regimen or lifestyle.

Scientific References

1. Anderson JW et al. “Health benefits of dietary fiber.”Nutrition Reviews, 2009.

2. Vulevic J et al. “Influence of prebiotic fiber on the human gut microbiota and immune function.”British Journal of Nutrition, 2013.

3. O’Keefe SJ. “The association between dietary fiber deficiency and high colorectal cancer risk.”Nature Reviews Gastroenterology & Hepatology, 2016.

4. Hall KD & Guo J. “Obesity energetics: body weight regulation and the effects of diet composition.”Gastroenterology, 2017.

5. Sandstrom B. “Micronutrient interactions: effects of phytic acid on zinc absorption.”American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 2001.

6. Hunt JR. “Bioavailability of iron, zinc, and other trace minerals from vegetarian diets.”American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 2003.

7. Slavin JL. “Dietary fiber and body weight.”Nutrition, 2005.

8. Deehan EC & Walter J. “The fiber gap and altered gut microbiome: current knowledge and future directions.”Journal of Nutrition, 2016.

9. Klurfeld DM. “What is the role of dietary fiber in human health?”Critical Reviews in Food Science and Nutrition, 2015.

10. Witwer E. “The role of fiber in digestion and nutrient absorption.”Annual Review of Nutrition, 2018.